3.6
18
votes
Rating
18 Stila Cosmetics Reviews & Complaints
Looking for a different brand? See All Skincare Brands.
Disclaimer: Research-backed info for entertainment only. Reviews are user-generated.
Copyright © 2026 Exposing Skincare
Copyright © 2026 Exposing Skincare
Stila has been one of those brands that randomly keeps showing up in my makeup bag over the years. I’ll try something new, forget about it, then somehow end up buying another Stila product six months later. 😂 I especially love their eye makeup because it gives me that “I actually know what I’m doing” look even when I absolutely do not. I wore one of the products to dinner recently and it stayed put the whole night. Came home, took my makeup off, and thought, okayyy, you did your job.
I bought the save the day 10-in-1 daily skincare elixir and it was a complete mess. The pump constantly clogs, forcing product to shoot across the bathroom wall.
The eyeliner has survived an entire workday, a workout, and one very unexpected crying session. I wish I were joking. It stayed where I put it and still looked decent by the evening. That’s basically my definition of a good eyeliner.
Stila has some really easy-to-use makeup products, especially for creating quick eye looks. The formulas are pigmented and blend nicely, although longevity can vary between products.
I ordered two of the Heaven’s Hue Highlighters online, and they arrived completely shattered and separated into a crumbly, dry mess inside the compacts.
For an expensive luxury eyeshadow, the formula stability is terrible. When you try to apply it after it begins drying out, the glitter flakes right off the wand, dropping chunky silver fallout all over your under eyes and scratching your eyelids. It’s a complete waste of money.
I still love the liquid eyeliner because it lasts longer than most brands I’ve tried and is easy to apply. On the other hand, some newer products haven’t impressed me as much and seem overpriced for the quality. Mixed experience overall, but there are still a few items I would repurchase.
This stay all day waterproof liquid eyeliner is one of the best I’ve used. Easy to apply, super precise, and actually stays put all day.
hit or miss tbh. eyeliner is great but some other stuff felt meh. quality seems inconsistent which is annoying.
the quality of Stila’s products are excellent and holds up well, especially the bestsellers
I tried their liquid lip color and found it drying. Felt fine at first but tight after a few hours.
Love how the Stay All Day liner actually lasts through my long shifts
They can flake after a few hours unless you use a good primer underneath.
Stila’s Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is one of my favorite makeup products! It glides on smoothly, and once it’s on, it doesn’t budge. I’ve tried other eyeliners, but none compare to the intensity and longevity of Stila’s formula. Perfect for all-day wear, and the precision tip makes it easy to apply
Burned slightly upon application.
Gives me an amazing glow and layers beautifully under sunscreen.
The eye make up lasts long, no need to retouch and nicely packaged too.
Love how fresh and clean my skin feels after using it.