3.5
24
votes
Rating
24 Eyeko Reviews & Complaints
Looking for a different brand? See All Skincare Brands.
Disclaimer: Research-backed info for entertainment only. Reviews are user-generated.
Copyright © 2026 Exposing Skincare
Copyright © 2026 Exposing Skincare
Eyeko’s eye makeup is great when I want defined lashes without spending twenty minutes trying to make everything look even. The mascara gives my lashes a nice lift, although I noticed a little smudging by the end of a long day. Still, it performs well enough for everyday makeup.
The mascara gives me the dramatic lashes I want, and I like how well it holds up during the day. Removing it at night, however, is another story. I find some of the formulas surprisingly stubborn to take off.
Claims to be smudge-proof, but I ended up with raccoon eyes after just 4 hours at my office job. Flaked constantly into my eyes throughout the afternoon, causing irritation for contact lens wearers.
The mascara gives me the look I wanted, but I found the formula started getting drier sooner than expected. The compact packaging is convenient for my makeup bag.
The mascara adds impressive length and volume without clumping or smudging. It stays in place all day and removes easily at night.
The black magic mascara gives incredible curl and length. I love the squeeze tube because you can use every last drop without it drying out!
I really liked the mascara at first, especially the brush, but it started getting dry sooner than I expected. The packaging is cute and compact, but I was disappointed that the formula didn’t last longer.
I liked the mascara during the first few uses, but mine became dry much sooner than I expected. Shipping was fast, but I was disappointed with how quickly the product seemed to lose its freshness.
The mascara stays put all day and doesn’t smudge. I especially love how easy it is to remove at night.
The squeezy tube packaging is genius because it lets you warm up the product and use every last drop without it drying out prematurely. It lifts, volumizes, and curls my lashes beautifully without a single smudge or flake all day.
Eyeko mascara adds impressive length and stays in place all day. It doesn’t smudge easily, even after long hours.
The squeezy tube packaging is brilliant because it allows you to warm up the product in your hands and ensure you get every last drop without it drying out prematurely.
The mascara and eyeliner are easy to apply and long-lasting. Great for everyday makeup looks.
The mascara gave nice length and didn’t smudge much during the day. My complaint is that it dried out fairly quickly.
The mascara runs during warm weather…
Their waterproof mascara really lasts all day and doesn’t smudge on me even in warm weather.
Their Black Magic Mascara is unreal, length, curl, and zero flaking. It’s a staple in my kit now. But you’ll need a powerful make up remover for this one!
Gives me the most dramatic lashes without clumping. The slim tube fits easily in my makeup bag. Lasts all day with no smudges.
The mascara felt heavy but holds all day. I’m still happy using it.
Their mascaras really do stay put and make my lashes look longer. The skinny brush is perfect for lower lashes. Just wish they removed a little easier, I hate having panda eyes at night
the mascara felt heavy when applied and patchy. I’d rather go for a light, smooth finish.
Natural ingredients and no breakouts.
Eyeko’s Black Magic Mascara lifts and holds a curl all day
I really liked the brown shade and the fine tip, but the formula felt dry right from the start. It was hard to get a smooth, even line, and the color came out patchy. I expected it to glide on better. A bit disappointing.