11 Caswell-Massey Reviews & Complaints
Looking for a different brand? See All Skincare Brands.
Caswell-Massey is praised for its heritage and traditional formulas, particularly their bar soaps and colognes.
Reviewers enjoy the classic, masculine scents and vintage appeal.
However, some feel certain products lean more nostalgic than functional.
Overall takeaway: A historic American grooming brand with old-school charm—ideal for those drawn to classic scents and style.
* Generated from real customer experiences.
I bought these soaps for display and the nostalgia it gave me.
I bought the Caswell Massey Almond Hand Cream cause my grandma used to have their soaps. The smell hit me with memories right away. I keep it in my purse and use it after grocery shopping cause my hands get dry. Tube is small tho so I run out fast.
Classic bar soaps with great lather and gentle formula. Nostalgic scent profile and they last surprisingly long. Highly recommend.
the soap looks cute and smells good, it’s a 10/10 for me!
Soap scents are retro and nostalgic.
Just like ordinary soaps available in the market. Scent fades instantly.
I grew up with my dad using Caswell-Massey, so I bought a few soaps for nostalgia. They smell classic and feel old-school, but the scent fades fast and they’re not as moisturizing as I hoped.
Scent faded fast, felt dated. Packaging nice, but overall underwhelming.
This brand has a lot of heritage and charm, and I like their apothecary-style aesthetic. I tried the Number Six Cologne and some bath soaps—nice scents, but not very long-lasting. It’s more of a nostalgic experience than high-performance grooming. Good for gifting or if you love classic American brands, but not a modern staple for me.
Average performance, decent hydration.
This soap is soothing to the skin. I love its lasting scent.