71 Carrot & Stick Reviews & Complaints

3.7 71 votes

Rating

Name*

Email*

Rating

72 Reviews

Most Voted

Newest Oldest

Inline Feedbacks

View all comments

Kay

6 months ago

Rating :

I have been using these products for 2 years. Love the serums and moistrizer. Wish they had more cleansers but I am happy with a generic drugstore cleanser.

Kam B

8 months ago

Rating :

Loved the products and the simplicity of the Day & Night set – my skin felt and looked better and my routine morning and night was super quick. I just ordered once (which is more expensive than subscription). I didn’t want to do the subscription until I had tried them. I wish they were more affordable, if you receive them every 8 weeks, it would add to over $1000 a year and I feel they are too expensive for the quantity, also it creates a lot of small plastic bottle waste. C&S might want to think about providing the products in larger quantities, and perhaps keeping the small sized ones for travel sizes.

Din

9 months ago

Rating :

These products are amazing. Highly rated.

Arielle

11 months ago

Rating :

This is the perfect balance between lightweight and deeply moisturizing. My skin feels refreshed and smooth without any stickiness.

R. Gallagher

1 year ago

Rating :

My friend recommended me this brand and it worked well for me

Sienna S.

8 months ago

Rating :

Their eye cream absorbs quickly without leaving a greasy residue, making it suitable for daily use.

L Lorb

8 months ago

Rating :

Love the products, clean ingredients and make my skin look amazing.

Tor

5 months ago

Rating :

I wouldnt purchase on Amazon. Products on Amazon could be not fresh or not authentic. Always buy from the brand.

Bella

6 months ago

Rating :

Use the Day & Night routine. I like these products are they mainly contain actives. Don’t like the peel, as it’s too strong. These products do not have any odour.

Leslie Workman

7 months ago

Rating :

Why haven’t I found out of this product sooner? It was worth every dollar

AvidM

5 months ago

Rating :

Products are expensive but worth it, especially the serums. A little goes a long way.

I wish they had a mineral spf.

Trudy V.

9 months ago

Rating :

The eye cream actually softened my fine lines without any irritation. Worth every penny

Ellen Channing

11 months ago

Rating :

Very moisturizing! My under-eyes feel hydrated all day without any greasiness. The glass jar packaging gives it a high-end feel.

Chace G.

11 months ago

Rating :

I’m all for budget-friendly skincare, so when this brand started popping up everywhere, I had to give it a go. Definitely worth the hype!

User

5 months ago

Rating :

Need usage instructions

Brandon

7 months ago

Rating :

Tried their moisturizer. The texture was off-putting, and my skin didn’t improve. Maybe it’s not for my skin type, but it was disappointing.

Selena Hall

7 months ago

Rating :

It effectively reduced dark circles and left the skin feeling plump and youthful.

Cristina H.

8 months ago

Rating :

Invested in their skincare line, expecting miracles. The products felt luxurious but didn’t deliver noticeable results. Perhaps I expected too much, but it felt like a letdown.

Meg G

9 months ago

Rating :

Scam Alert! I wish I had found this page before I placed my order. According to Carrot, my order was delivered…it was not! Plus they added an additional shipping cost, which I did not approve. I was worried that this was a scam and now I really think it is a scam. Looks like the product is not worth it and they do not guarantee the product nor will they grant refunds! Be careful before you place an order.

Mollie Ann Brook

9 months ago

Rating :

cancelled subscription before order shipped and it has been 7 business days and still no refund.
very overpriced for a generic product.

Meg G

9 months ago

Reply to Mollie Ann Brook

Wish I had read this before I ordered…looks like we both lost our $ from this company.

Delores F.

1 year ago

Rating :

I tried Carrot & Stick The Repair Cream, and it’s deeply moisturizing without feeling too heavy. My skin felt softer and plumper after a few uses.

Blanchard

1 year ago

Rating :

This cream is a lifesaver for dry, winter skin. It’s rich and nourishing but doesn’t clog my pores.

Jamie Matthews

1 year ago

Rating :

I tried their repair serum and they were not kidding about its fast results. Great job!

Imogen

1 year ago

Rating :

One of the best brand for any skin care!

Nasreen T

1 month ago

Rating :

Scam Alert!
I ordered the Multi-Lift Moisturizer, and it took three weeks to arrive. When it finally did, the container was already half empty. There is no working phone number or email available to submit a complaint. Based on my experience, I would not recommend purchasing this product.

eden K

1 month ago

Rating :

13 days waiting for this order to be shipped. when contacted the company they replied that they will check with their fulfillment center and let me know. They should check before replying to me. It seems to me that this is a scam of a company.

Com

4 months ago

Rating :

Purchase on the brands website. The Amazon products are not directly from the company.

Barb

5 months ago

Rating :

These products are perfect for middle aged and older skin

Siddall Sheila

6 months ago

Rating :

Get it from Amazon Prime. I don’t trust the company website. Especially after reading about all the problems. Product is okay. Definitely overpriced!

Brianna

1 year ago

Rating :

The best brand for skin routine products! Highly recommended even for someone who has sensitive skin!

Imogen

1 year ago

Rating :

The best brand ! highly recommended they have top notch products

August S.

1 year ago

Rating :

One of the most recommended skin care products!

Danielle P.

5 days ago

Rating :

I like it overall. The product feels good and my skin looks brighter. But the pump on mine was weird and it would spit out too much at once. Like calm down lol. If they fixed the packaging I’d rate higher. The formula seems solid though.

Carisha H.

16 days ago

Rating :

Not worth the hype!

Troy A.

16 days ago

Rating :

I bought Carrot Stick products with a holiday discount. I wanted something natural for my sensitive skin, but they made my face feel oily and clogged. Not the result I hoped for.

LV1

1 month ago

Rating :

❤️❤️. Great resource.

feedback20@gmail.com

1 month ago

Rating :

Great site. Wish more brands could be removed.

FRE

1 month ago

Rating :

Great resource. Can you include ingredients?

Charlotte Sharp

1 month ago

Rating :

Suggested by my cousin and I am really happy that they did so because I wouldn’t have found out about this wonderful brand. It really saved my skin from never ending outbreaks

Ing

3 months ago

Rating :

Could you include ingredient analysis

TDI

3 months ago

Rating :

This is a great resource with real comments

S D E

3 months ago

Rating :

Amazing products

Packaging

3 months ago

Rating :

Need to improve airless containers

D E

4 months ago

Rating :

Is there a better brandf?

CharmingG

5 months ago

Rating :

I did the research. These products have the best ingredients. However packaging is not good.

john Spiv

6 months ago

Rating :

I tried Carrot and Stick eye cream for over two weeks and found it useless. There was no change to the dark circles under my eyes.

Delia

8 months ago

Rating :

I was drawn in by the sleek packaging and clean ingredient list, but after using the moisturizer for a week, my skin became congested, and I developed small bumps on my forehead.It didn’t live up to the hype for me.

Senna Lacey

8 months ago

Rating :

Too overhyped!

Nala H.

9 months ago

Rating :

not effective for my skin

Delia Sharp

10 months ago

Rating :

Expensive but delivers drugstore-level results. No real improvements in my skin, and the textures feel off. Just another overpriced, trendy brand.

Arizona Robbins

11 months ago

Rating :

For the price, I expected way better results. The formulas feel heavy, and I didn’t notice any improvement in my skin at all.

Romaine V.

11 months ago

Rating :

requested a refund, but it took weeks and several follow-ups before they processed it.

Anna Kellog

1 year ago

Rating :

I reached out to Carrot & Stick about a delayed shipment, and the response felt generic. They resolved it eventually, but I expected more effort to make it right.

Aimee

1 year ago

Rating :

I recently purchased the Repair Serum from Carrot & Stick, and I’m hoping that this product will help with my wrinkles. I haven’t seen a huge effect on my skin yet, but I feel like it is working.

Trina V.

1 year ago

Rating :

Their moisturizer didn’t moisturize my skin enough

Kate M.

1 year ago

Rating :

I don’t see the hype for this brand. It just doesn’t suit my skin type.

Rosie

1 year ago

Rating :

Anti aging serum is a huge help for me. wrinkles and lines are gone and tightens

Yana

1 year ago

Rating :

Not worth the hype.

Elena C

1 year ago

Rating :

The Anti-aging serum is a must try. I just tried it for few weeks and I can see very visible results,In additional also try the moiturizer surely would help dry skin!

Phoebe Adams

1 year ago

Rating :

I like how the product works gentle on my sensitive skin, The price is fair the effect is above expectations.

Millicent Knight

1 year ago

Rating :

A minimal result after using it in just few days. A good product

EdithTaylor

1 year ago

Rating :

Don’t fall for the hype! too pricey item

Henny Viernes

1 year ago

Rating :

Pricey item! not worth the money

Bernice

1 year ago

Rating :

Carrot & Stick products are overhyped. Despite their claims of combining natural ingredients with science, I found them ineffective.

Paola

1 year ago

Rating :

I bought this product a few weeks ago and it worked on my skin so far. I saw visible results.

Janet D.

1 year ago

Rating :

Good product. I heard so many things about it but it’s not worth the hype. The result is not what I expected.

Cami Anne L.

1 year ago

Rating :

Price is too much. You can achieve the same results with cheaper products.

Hazel

1 year ago

Rating :

Too pricey. Eye cream didn’t even work.

Shelly Cooper

1 year ago

Rating :

Carrot & Stick’s toner worked wonders for my acne-prone skin! It helped to clear up my breakouts and keep my skin balanced.

-1

Curtis Singer

1 year ago

Rating :

Superb product! One of the best I’ve tried since 2020. Love their moisturizer, effective for dry skin and anti-aging.

-1

Pamela A.

1 year ago

Rating :

I love their products! been using them for months and they don’t disappoint.

-1